Key concerns related to the Office of Governor in India

FEDERAL GAP

1. F - Federal Undermining via Partisan Conduct
• Governors act as political agents of the Centre instead of being neutral custodians of the Constitution.
• Example: Arunachal Pradesh (2016) – Governor’s role led to the dismissal of the elected government, later reversed by the Supreme Court.
2. E - Executive Overreach & Governance Paralysis
• Governors interfere in state administration, bypassing the elected Council of Ministers (Article 163).
• Example: Delhi (2023) – Lieutenant Governor clashed with the elected government over control of bureaucratic appointments.
3. D - Delay in Legislative Process (Bill Assent Issues)
• Excessive delay or withholding of assent to state Bills leads to legislative paralysis and constitutional deadlock.
• Example: Punjab (2023) – Governor withheld assent to Bills for two years, prompting Supreme Court intervention.
4. E - Electoral Mandate Distortion in Government Formation
• Governors misuse discretionary powers in inviting political parties to form governments in a hung assembly.
• Example: Maharashtra (2019) – Governor Koshyari swore in a Chief Minister without a proven majority, leading to an 80-hour government.
5. R - Rash Imposition of President’s Rule
• Article 356 (President’s Rule) is misused to destabilize opposition-led state governments.
• Example: Uttarakhand (2016) – Governor recommended President’s Rule just before a scheduled floor test.
6. A - Autocratic Control Over University Appointments
• As Chancellors, Governors interfere in Vice-Chancellor selections, sidelining state governments.
• Example: West Bengal (2023) – Governor unilaterally appointed VCs, sparking legal battles.
7. L - Lack of Accountability & Constitutional Safeguards
• Governors are accountable only to the President (Article 156) and cannot be impeached, leading to unfettered discretion.
• Example: No constitutional provision for impeachment, making Governors unaccountable despite holding significant authority.
8. G - Governance Stalemate Due to Assent Delays
• Despite Article 200, Governors delay Bill assent, undermining the legislative supremacy of states.
• Example: Tamil Nadu (2023) – Governor delayed 12 Bills, leading to judicial intervention.
9. A - Ambiguous Role in State Autonomy
• Governors’ undefined role in cooperative federalism leads to frequent conflicts with state governments.
• Example: West Bengal (2023) – Governor and state government locked in disputes over governance powers.
10. P - Political Bias in Decision-Making
• Governors act in favor of ruling parties at the Centre, violating constitutional morality and the basic structure doctrine.
• Example: Karnataka (2018) – Governor gave a political party 15 days to prove a majority, later reduced to 24 hours by the Supreme Court.

“FEDERAL GAP” reminds us how these issues erode cooperative federalism, democratic principles, and constitutional governance in India.

International Best Practices for Eliminating Manual Scavenging

United Kingdom: Strict Legal Enforcement and Technological Innovation
Health and Safety at Work Act, 1974 – Legally mandates that no worker should enter confined spaces without protective equipment and safety protocols.

Strict Penalties for Non-Compliance – Any employer forcing workers into unsafe conditions faces heavy fines and imprisonment.

United States: Advanced Occupational Safety and Workers’ Rights
Automated Sewer Maintenance Systems – Use of CCTV sewer inspection technology and self-cleaning pipelines minimizes human entry.
Government-Funded Worker Training – The U.S. Department of Labor mandates periodic skill training for sewer maintenance workers.

Japan: Smart Sewer Systems and Urban Planning for Sanitation Safety
Advanced Wastewater Treatment Plants – Waste is processed through high-tech filtration plants, eliminating the need for manual handling.

City-Wide Adoption of AI in Waste Management – AI predicts blockages and maintenance needs, preventing emergency manual cleaning situations.

Singapore: High-Tech Waste Management and Zero Manual Handling
Pneumatic Waste Disposal System – Underground vacuum pipes transport waste, reducing manual cleaning.
Sanitation as a Respected Profession – Workers are highly paid and recognized for their essential contribution.

Best Practices and Examples of Urban Transformation in India 

Kumbh Mela: A Model for Temporary Urbanization: The 2025 Kumbh Mela in Prayagraj showcased rapid infrastructure development, AI surveillance, and smart city solutions. 

30 pontoon bridges and 92 renovated roads ensured smooth traffic movement. 
AI-enabled surveillance with 2,700 CCTV cameras and drones enhanced safety and crowd management. 
The event generated $2.7 billion in economic activity, highlighting urban planning’s economic potential. 

Indore’s Waste Management Model: Indore's decentralized waste management system achieved 100% waste segregation at source. 
The city implemented strict monitoring, citizen engagement, and composting units to reduce landfill dependency. 

Indore has consistently ranked as India’s cleanest city in  Swachh Survekshan rankings since 2017. 

Urban Traffic Management: Chandigarh’s AI Traffic Systemautomates violation detection with 2,000+ CCTV cameras, ensuring seamless rule enforcement. 

Kolkata’s Real-Time Traffic Management adjusts signals using AI to reduce wait times and improve vehicle movement. 

Bengaluru’s Sustainable Mobility Initiatives: Metro expansion projects and electric bus fleets aim to reduce congestion and emissions. 
Integration of last-mile connectivity with electric vehicles and bicycle-sharing programs enhances accessibility. 

The Namma Metro Phase-2 expansion will cover 72 km, reducing travel time by 40%. 

Chennai’s Water Management Reforms: By implementing mandatory rainwater harvesting, Chennai has enhanced its water quality and significantly raised groundwater levels.  

The city now fulfills 15% of its water demand through recycling, and 8% of treated wastewater is sold to industries. 

Other Best Practices: 

Visakhapatnam built India’s first park designed for differently-abled children, featuring sensory experiences, wheelchair accessibility, and safe play zones to promote inclusive urban spaces. 

Jabalpur’s 311 App enables citizens to access civic services, report grievances, and track public infrastructure issues. The app ensures direct governance interaction and real-time resolution. 

Surat’s Integrated Command and Control Centre for Urban Management integrates IT systems for city surveillance, traffic control, and emergency response. The system enhances urban governance, citizen safety, and municipal efficiency. 

Nashik adopted a multi-level flood preparedness plan, integrating GIS mapping, real-time alerts, and coordinated rescue operations, significantly reducing disaster impact on urban infrastructure. 

Chennai transformed Pondy Bazaar into a pedestrian-friendly promenade, enhancing walkability, urban aesthetics, and local business engagement, making cities more livable. 

Key issues hindering the effectiveness of RTI


“DARKNESS”

(Delays, Amendments, Resistance, Knowledge gap, National security exemptions, Endangerment of activists, Skewed representation, Secrecy misuse)

D – Delays in Information Disclosure
• RTI mandates a response within 30 days, but officials often violate deadlines.
• Justice is delayed, especially in cases of human rights violations, environmental clearances, and corruption inquiries.
• Example: A 2022 report revealed that 12 out of 29 information commissions in India have a waiting time of over one year to hear appeals.

A – Amendments that Weaken RTI
• RTI (Amendment) Act, 2019 gave the government control over the tenure and salaries of Information Commissioners, compromising their autonomy.
• DPDP Act, 2023 amended Section 8(1) of RTI, exempting all personal information from disclosure, even if it involves public officials.
• Example: These changes reduce transparency, making it harder to expose corruption and inefficiencies.

R – Resistance from Bureaucracy and Political Parties
• Public officials often delay or deny information, fearing exposure.
• Some institutions refuse to appoint Public Information Officers (PIOs), making access difficult.
• Political parties also defy RTI, limiting scrutiny of their funding.
• Example: In 2023-24, nearly 42% of RTI appeals to the Central Information Commission (CIC) were returned without hearing.

K – Knowledge Gap Among Citizens
• Many people, especially in rural areas, remain unaware of their RTI rights.
• Government efforts to promote RTI awareness remain weak, leading to underutilization.
• Example: A PWC study found that only 12% of rural and 30% of urban populations knew about the RTI Act.

N – National Security and Exemption Misuse
• Government agencies misuse national security concerns to deny information requests.
• 27 security agencies, including RAW, IB, and CERT-In, are exempt from RTI under the Second Schedule.
• Example: The Official Secrets Act, 1923, is often cited to refuse disclosures, even when they involve public interest.

E – Endangerment of RTI Activists and Whistleblowers
• RTI activists face harassment, violence, and even murder, discouraging transparency efforts.
• The Whistleblower Protection Act, 2014, remains poorly implemented.
• Example: Since 2006, 99 RTI activists have been killed and 180 assaulted (Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative Report).

S – Skewed Gender Representation
• RTI institutions are male-dominated, limiting a gender-sensitive perspective on transparency issues.
• Example: Since 2005, only 9% of all information commissioners have been women, and 12 out of 29 commissions have never had a woman commissioner.

S – Secrecy and Misuse of RTI
• While RTI is a tool for transparency, it is sometimes misused for frivolous queries, diverting resources.
• Example: An RTI was once filed to count the number of cattle in a region, highlighting how trivial queries burden public offices.

👆Mnemonic - For All Constitutional Bodies :-

🔘 Credit :- Subha. (Channel Member)

Join 🔜 = ©@MnemonicsNotesUPSC.

#PleaseShare.

Andaman and Nicobar islands (North to south)
Trick- No MS Little Nick Can Not Let Go.
N- North Andaman
M- Middle Andaman
S- South Andaman
L-Little Andaman
C- Car Nicobar
L- Little Nicobar
G- Great Nicobar